Family law
  • Home
  • Divorce
    • The Divorce Process in South Africa
    • Rule 41A Mediation
    • The Marital Property Regimes >
      • Marriage in Community of Property
      • Marriage out of community without accrual
      • Marriage out of community with the inclusion of the accrual
      • Universal Partnerships
      • Register Antenuptial Contract Online
      • Changing your matrimonial regime.
    • Division of Assets at Divorce >
      • Forfeiture of Assets in a Divorce
    • Evicting your spouse divorce
    • Retirement Funds and Divorce
    • Living Annuities
    • Hiding Assets in a Divorce
    • Trusts and Divorce
    • Divorce a Missing Spouse
    • Adultery and Suing a Third Party
    • Domicile in Divorce Cases
    • International Divorces in South Africa
    • International Divorce Law >
      • UK Divorce Laws
    • Choosing a Divorce Attorney
    • On-line Divorce
    • Lawyer Fees and Costs
    • Important Aspects of a Divorce
    • Dealing with Emotions During Divorce and Separation
    • Divorce Statistics
    • Divorce Therapy and Counselling >
      • Marriage and Relationship Therapists
    • Rebuilding Your Financial Life
    • Divorce Attorney Cape Town
    • Divorce Polls
    • Ingredients of a successful relationship
    • Uncontested Divorce
    • Uncontested Divorce - What Happens on the Court Day?
  • Maintenance
    • Maintenance Child COVID19
    • Spousal maintenance
    • How to calculate Child Maintenance?
    • Maintenance Defaulters
    • What Happens if you don't pay child maintenance
    • Child Maintenance Frequently Asked Questions
    • Rule 43 Interim Maintenance Pending Divorce >
      • Can I appeal a Rule 43 Order
      • Apply for Costs in Rule 43
      • Financial Disclosure Rule 43
      • Rule 43 Maintenance
    • The Maintenance Manual
    • Grand Parents and Maintenance
  • Children
    • Custody and Coronavirus
    • Relocation and Child Abduction >
      • International Child Custody Law South Africa
      • Tips on international child custody
    • Unmarried Parents and the Law
    • Parenting Plans >
      • Conflict and dispute-resolution mechanisms
    • The non-custodian parent and contact
    • Appointing a Guardian in a Will
    • Introducing a new partner to your child
    • Refusal of Contact
    • Suspending Parental Rights
    • Parental Alienation
    • Facilitation
    • Living Arrangements
    • Joint decisions about your child
    • Paternity Disputes
    • The Family Advocate
    • Parenting during separartion
    • Children's Act 38 of 2005
  • Abuse
    • Gender Based Violence in South Africa
    • Domestic Abuse Forms
    • Domestic Violence Corona Virus
    • Divorcing an Abusive Spouse
    • What is Coercive Control?
    • What is Emotional Abuse
    • What is Sexual Abuse
    • What is Financial Abuse
    • What is Stalking
    • What is Verbal Abuse
    • What is Spiritual Abuse
    • What is Social Abuse
    • Revenge Porn
    • Steps to obtain a Protection Order
    • Domestic Violence eBook
    • The Protection Order
    • Who Qualifies for a Protection Order
    • Breaching a Protection Order
    • Questions on Domestic Abuse
    • Signs of an Abusive Relationship
    • Domestic Violence Information
    • Harassment
  • Cohabitation
    • Maintenance and Cohabitation
    • Sample Cohabitation Agreement
    • Engagement and the law
    • Formalities for marriage in south africa
  • Same Sex
  • Family Law eBooks
  • Family Law Links
    • The South African Court System
    • Court Rolls
    • Family Law Legislation
    • Family Law Blog
    • Family Law Newsletter March 2017
    • September 2016 Family Law Newsletter
    • Family Law Newsletter 2017 1
    • New Family Law Cases
    • Family Law Matters
    • Register for the Online Family Law Course
    • Online Family Law Education
  • About the Author
  • Contact
  • Charities

Can one appeal a Rule 43 Order?


Appealing a Rule 43 Court Order


​S v S (19332/2017) [2017] ZAGPPHC 1041
 
It is an inevitable fact of modern life that marriages often end in divorce. Based on data from Statistics South Africa, 25 326 divorce orders in courts were approved in 2016. Of these, 55% involved children under the age of 18 years.
 
Applicants in rule 43 applications are mostly women who, as in the majority countries, occupy the lowest economic rung and are usually in a less favourable financial position than their husbands.  The gender imbalance in homes and society in general continues to be a challenge both for society at large and our courts. This is especially noticeable in applications for maintenance where systemic failures to impose maintenance orders have negatively impacted the rule of law. It is women who are mainly left to nurture their children and shoulder the related financial burden.
 
In the majority divorce cases, one of the parties approaches the court to rule on an application in terms of rule 43 of the Rules of Court (Uniform Rules or Rules) for interim relief, pendente lite (pending divorce and litigation).
 
Rule 43 of the High Court rules offers a mechanism for a spouse in divorce proceedings to approach the court for an interim order granting them child and/or spousal maintenance pending finalization of the divorce. It has always been a well-established fact that these orders cannot be appealed. However, a question which always came to mind was whether this principle was constitutional?
 
The Constitutional Court was recently requested to decide this very question in the case of S v S. The parties in this case in a divorce action approached the Court after an order for maintenance had been granted against the Husband for an amount of maintenance that exceeded the amount he had offered during the application. The husband, after being unsuccessful in the High Court approached the Supreme Court of Appeal.
 
The appeal was dismissed on the basis that Rule 43 orders were not appealable. The basis for this was to protect the best interests of the child in circumstances where children may be prejudiced by continuous appeals. He then proceeded to the Constitutional Court to dispute the constitutionality of the refusal of the Supreme Court to entertain his application.
 
The Husband contended that his right to equality and access to courts had been being infringed as well as the rights of the child in this instance given that it was, he who wanted custody of the children. As such he would be taking care of them.
 
The question then before the court was: will the prohibition infringe the best interests of the child? Furthermore, does it infringe the right to equal protection of the law? And, does it infringe the right to access courts?
 
In reply to these questions the court found the following: The appeal procedure may cause substantial delays and as such leave the children or spouses that require the maintenance destitute. Should any Rule 43 order not serve the best interest of the child – it could be determined on a case by case basis and if needed it can be varied.
 
When dealing with the second issue raised being equality – the court found that Rule 43 provides an essential purpose: to “provide a speedy and inexpensive remedy, primarily for the benefit of women and children”. So, the court held that to permit an appeal would ruin the very purpose which Rule 43 seeks to advance. The prohibition has a legitimate purpose.
 
And finally, regarding access to courts, the court held that a litigant nevertheless had access to courts even though not within an appeal procedure. The court pointed out that a litigant could approach the court to alter the order if there is a change in “material circumstances”: which may possibly justify it.
 
In this case the husband had argued that his estranged wife had obtained employment and also that she was residing with her new lover whom was in part maintaining her. These may be grounds which he could argue in an application for variation.
 
The appeal was consequently dismissed.
 
What can one do if dissatisfied with a Rule 43 order?
 
As mentioned above, although you may not be able to approach the courts to appeal a Rule 43, you could certainly approach it to vary an order. Nevertheless, in order to be successful, you would need to establish that there was a change in “material circumstances” that justify the variation.
 
Both litigants can approach for a variation on any kind of ground which it believes is a change in material circumstances and that they can prove to court. Whether or not that is to increase or decrease the maintenance amount or for a change in the primary caregiver, etc.
 
Rule 43 is a crucial mechanism that if employed correctly will provide maintenance for yourself and your children although the divorce is pending. Divorce proceedings could take some time to finalize and with an order such as this in place will go a long way to ensuring financial security during the uncertainty of the proceedings.
s_v_s_rule_43_judgement_27_june_2019.pdf
File Size: 378 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Main Menu

Cohabitation and Living Together
Engagement and the Law
Formalities of Marriage in South Africa
Same-Sex Relationships
Unmarried Parents and Children
Parental Rights and Responsibilities
Care and Contact (Custody) of Children
Divorce In South Africa
Divorce Process in South Africa
Division of Assets in Divorce
Divorce and Retirement Funds
Rule 43 and Interim Maintenance
Divorce a Missing Spouse
Adultery, Suing a Third Party
International Divorces in South African Courts
Parental Rights
Child Maintenance
Spousal Maintenance
Domestic Violence and Abuse

Family and Divorce Law Links

Family Law Links
Family Law Legislation

Family Law Matters
Court Judgements
Court Rolls

Online Services

Online DIY Divorce
Online Managed Divorce
Online Antenuptial Contracts
​

Partner Services

Family Law Mediation
Collaborative Divorce
Divorce Attorney Cape Town

Contact Details

BERTUS PRELLER
​MAURICE PHILLIPS WISENBERG

20th Floor, 2 Long  Street, Cape Town, 8001, South Africa
Telephone: +27 21 419 7115


​
Email: familylaw@mpw.co.za
Facebook: divorceattorneys
Twitter: @bertuspreller

Family and Divorce Law Blogs

Divorce Attorney 

Social Networks

Picture
Picture
Picture
© 2020-  All content on this website is under copyright of  LawSplash - All Rights Reserved.
Legal Notices
  • Home
  • Divorce
    • The Divorce Process in South Africa
    • Rule 41A Mediation
    • The Marital Property Regimes >
      • Marriage in Community of Property
      • Marriage out of community without accrual
      • Marriage out of community with the inclusion of the accrual
      • Universal Partnerships
      • Register Antenuptial Contract Online
      • Changing your matrimonial regime.
    • Division of Assets at Divorce >
      • Forfeiture of Assets in a Divorce
    • Evicting your spouse divorce
    • Retirement Funds and Divorce
    • Living Annuities
    • Hiding Assets in a Divorce
    • Trusts and Divorce
    • Divorce a Missing Spouse
    • Adultery and Suing a Third Party
    • Domicile in Divorce Cases
    • International Divorces in South Africa
    • International Divorce Law >
      • UK Divorce Laws
    • Choosing a Divorce Attorney
    • On-line Divorce
    • Lawyer Fees and Costs
    • Important Aspects of a Divorce
    • Dealing with Emotions During Divorce and Separation
    • Divorce Statistics
    • Divorce Therapy and Counselling >
      • Marriage and Relationship Therapists
    • Rebuilding Your Financial Life
    • Divorce Attorney Cape Town
    • Divorce Polls
    • Ingredients of a successful relationship
    • Uncontested Divorce
    • Uncontested Divorce - What Happens on the Court Day?
  • Maintenance
    • Maintenance Child COVID19
    • Spousal maintenance
    • How to calculate Child Maintenance?
    • Maintenance Defaulters
    • What Happens if you don't pay child maintenance
    • Child Maintenance Frequently Asked Questions
    • Rule 43 Interim Maintenance Pending Divorce >
      • Can I appeal a Rule 43 Order
      • Apply for Costs in Rule 43
      • Financial Disclosure Rule 43
      • Rule 43 Maintenance
    • The Maintenance Manual
    • Grand Parents and Maintenance
  • Children
    • Custody and Coronavirus
    • Relocation and Child Abduction >
      • International Child Custody Law South Africa
      • Tips on international child custody
    • Unmarried Parents and the Law
    • Parenting Plans >
      • Conflict and dispute-resolution mechanisms
    • The non-custodian parent and contact
    • Appointing a Guardian in a Will
    • Introducing a new partner to your child
    • Refusal of Contact
    • Suspending Parental Rights
    • Parental Alienation
    • Facilitation
    • Living Arrangements
    • Joint decisions about your child
    • Paternity Disputes
    • The Family Advocate
    • Parenting during separartion
    • Children's Act 38 of 2005
  • Abuse
    • Gender Based Violence in South Africa
    • Domestic Abuse Forms
    • Domestic Violence Corona Virus
    • Divorcing an Abusive Spouse
    • What is Coercive Control?
    • What is Emotional Abuse
    • What is Sexual Abuse
    • What is Financial Abuse
    • What is Stalking
    • What is Verbal Abuse
    • What is Spiritual Abuse
    • What is Social Abuse
    • Revenge Porn
    • Steps to obtain a Protection Order
    • Domestic Violence eBook
    • The Protection Order
    • Who Qualifies for a Protection Order
    • Breaching a Protection Order
    • Questions on Domestic Abuse
    • Signs of an Abusive Relationship
    • Domestic Violence Information
    • Harassment
  • Cohabitation
    • Maintenance and Cohabitation
    • Sample Cohabitation Agreement
    • Engagement and the law
    • Formalities for marriage in south africa
  • Same Sex
  • Family Law eBooks
  • Family Law Links
    • The South African Court System
    • Court Rolls
    • Family Law Legislation
    • Family Law Blog
    • Family Law Newsletter March 2017
    • September 2016 Family Law Newsletter
    • Family Law Newsletter 2017 1
    • New Family Law Cases
    • Family Law Matters
    • Register for the Online Family Law Course
    • Online Family Law Education
  • About the Author
  • Contact
  • Charities